Free standard shipping on full-size orders $50+
Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
While it does stay on, it's very smudgy and no matter how well you sharpen the pencil, it will never give you an even line. Definitely disappointed in this purchase.
This was so disappointing! The sample that came in my birchbox was amazing! So I ordered it in dark purple, and like other reviewers have stated... When you buy the full size liner, it doesnt work as well. It doesnt glide on at all, and literally wont even go on the inner lid-rim area no matter how many swipes i do. I love the color and I love the sample black i got in my box, but it is trully disappointing that the full product sucks.
When I first tried the sample of the Sumita eyeliner in Suman (Black) in my Birchbox, I thought, "Yes! I have finally found my eyeliner for life!" I bought it in regular size and what a letdown.
It doesn't look the same. It doesn't go on the same. In fact, it's a horrible liner. So now I just keep my little stub of a sample to usefor special occasions. And I'm still on the lookout for that perfect black liner. :(
I purchased a full size after much success with a Birchbox sample. The sample glided across my eyelid and left behind a great, deep black line that was clean and sharp. The eyeliner I purchased paled in comparison to the sample; it does not glide on smoothly, the line left behind is weak and affected by the base shadow on my lid. I've reverted to my previous department store brand and am looking for something different to try at Birchbox.
When I recieved my sample I was in heaven and quickly purchased not one but TWO full sized eyeliners...but everytime I tried to sharpen it the point would fall out...also I thought the creamy texture was so amazing until I realized it melted/smeared...I NEVER write bad reviews but honestly I would say stay away NOT WORTH YOUR MONEY! I had trouble with BOTH of the full sized liners purchased... :(
Love the product, it's a beautiful color and the gel is the perfect texture for easy application. That being said, it doesn't last very long and by not very long I really mean something like ten applications.
I'm not sure I would buy again, it's a reasonable price but not worth it for the limited amount of time it lasts. I can't constantly be worrying about whether I have eye liner for the day!
I was super excited to receive my black Sumita Color Contrast Eyeliner! I had really liked the Birchbox sample in Navy Blue that I had received with my subscription. One of the issues with the pencil is that it's really difficult to sharpen. I tried several different sharpeners. This problem wasn't as bad as the pencil completely drying out less than half-way down. I was really disappointed in this product and definitely did not get my money's worth.
I reviewed this product when I got it in my birchbox a few months ago and loved it. I've changed my mind. I don't know if I just got a bad pencil, but this is nothing like the sample I received before.
The eyeliner drys out really easily and barely produces any color. What color does come out will only show if I cut the tip of the eyeliner off every day or stand there re-lining my eye over and over for about 5 minutes. Even then, the color only lasts about an hour before it is all gone and you can't tell I put any on at all.
If all full-sized liners are like mine, do NOT buy it, you will be disappointed.
I am actually really disappointed with this product. I received the sample and loved the way it went on with ease and it looked sleek. I bought the full product and I am not sure why the difference but it seems dry and does not go on with ease.
I like the feeling putting it on, the look, the ease of use. Yet it smears too much. Not good for this contacts wearer.