Always Free Shipping for Birchbox Aces
Free standard shipping on orders $50+
Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
I was excited to try this product but it doesn't seem to ever dry. Just keeps running down my eyes and sticking to my eyelids . What a mess! Not happy with this product
Yes, easily slides onto your lid, but hard to control and kind of heavy. Not my favorite. I think I prefer liquid liners better - easier to control the pointed tip.
I was very excited to get the purple pencil in my box, but when I tried to use it it went on more roughly than any pencil I've ever used. The color was to hard and instead of rolling on smoothly, it caught on my eyelids and made a very patchy uneven line. My experience seems to be the odd one out, so maybe there's another problem but be careful!
I received a black one in my sample box. Not a fan. I have oily skin and the liner was running and smudging all day when I wore it.
Really great colors and stays on really well but when I had to sharpen the pencil I couldn't get a decent tip. Not worth it.
This eyeliner went on smooth, but the application was thick despite the sharp tip. If you are going for a smoky, heavy eye, this may be the product for you. As a minimalist that prefers a defined but not heavy eye, this product is not for me.
And no, I am not being overdramatic here. I really did love this set (especially the gray), but the wax/pencil part became separated from the wood/outside part, and literally would just fall out of the pencil when I took the cap off. I was pretty bummed, because this was a staple of basic eyeliner colors for me. Also, the gray was super smooth, but the purple, blue, and black weren't and would go on kind of...bumpily sometimes. As much as I want to, I can't recommend this set!
not a fan of this eyeliner… sadly i kept before knowing return policy otherwise would have returned… it seems flaky when i put on after 10 mins...
I bought this after my daughter recommended it to me. She bragged on the longevity of it after application. I had trouble getting this eyeliner to go on my eyelid without dragging. I keep trying but it still tends to skip and drag when I apply it.
I got this in my birchbox and loved it. The problem for me is that the soft wax is wonderful but the pencil is horrible. Every time I try to sharpen it the pencil doesn't sharpen properly and it tends to irritate the line. I really wish the packaging would change because I like the wax liner, but I can't do the pencil.