I feel like it's hard to review all of these at once. They're all very different lip balms. I am, however, very glad to have purchased these as a set as I would have sworn off the whole brand if I had tried the lip balm that I was most excited about out of these four.
The pomegranate was the first I tried. To say the least, I wasn't very impressed. It was very thick and left a coat of white (SPF?) on my lips.
I tried the mint next, and I still wasn't very impressed. It felt like a normal lip balm, nothing special. It definitely wasn't as thick as the pomegranate, which was a plus.
The berry was the third I tried and my personal favorite of the set. I felt as if this was the most moisturizing, and it felt heavenly on my lips.
The melon, like the mint, was nothing special. It was more moisturizing than the mint, though.
All four tasted wonderful, but taste isn't everything in a lip balm.
I'm set on lip balm for quite a while, I think, but even after I run out, I probably won't purchase these again.