I have been using birchbox for 13 months now. I have seen a lot of boxes and this has been the most confusing and disappointing item. Its not an "extra" as someone claimed - it was in my box and I only got 4 other samples, and one of those were toothpaste. I don't care if this is the world's greatest pen (its not). I sign up for birchbox to give me beauty products.
I received Toothpaste and a PEN in my birchbox! This is not right! There are other subscription services out there that will send out much bigger samples but I stay with birchbox out of a sense of loyalty and the belief that they do send quality items. But lately I've been getting TINY samples and now this box has this pen and toothpaste? Not cool