if this wouldn't smudge, this would be the perfect mascara.
It smells delicious, it looks pretty much edible from the very natural list of ingredients, and separates and lengthens so nicely.
The problem is it smudges, seriously. In fact, you can do a gentle scrape at your lashes and see the product under your nail. Or wipe gently with a tissue and see a whole ton of black on the tissue. It's now a habit of mine to use my finger to wipe my lower lid every now and then because I'll definitely have a smudge. But that's what you get for such an amazing ingredient list I guess :(