Pros: I love the big wand, and the fact that I can take it off with just water. In fact if you apply too much you just take some water, apply it to your lash and it slides off. Easy fix.
Cons: This out weighs being able to remove it. What you will find when using is that little particles will fall onto your face, in the area of under eye. Or they may even fall into your eye and cause irritation. I didn't know until after I had been using it for a while. In the middle of the day someone would point out that I have flakes of black on my face. Id remove them and then later more would appear. And when you apply this it does look like particles stuck to your lashes. Unlike normal mascara it seems to have a clumping affect of a sort.