Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
“Two-timing” is generally thought of as a negative thing, but not when it comes to eyeliner. These two-packs of specialized Mally shades are meant to go together. These surprisingly creamy pencils give you a smooth, precise line that’s not only waterproof, but adamantly rub-proof as well. Each duo comes with one Midnight black pencil and one color liner, so don’t feel guilty about doubling up.
This eyeliner exceeds expectations! Goes on very smooth (feels almost silky). Lasts all day and into the night. I have not had problems with smudging at all. Love the color Sailor which is a great blue. Definitely worth trying.4
Did not get this in my birch box but I have used it before. Makes me feel beautiful. I love makeup that is minimal and natural and that's what I got from this5
These eyeliners are phenomenal! They stay all day and they stay in my water line too!! Great product! Doesn't move once it sets! Waterproof too!5
This eyeliner does last all day. It goes on smooth. Color is great. It may smudge a little but this pencil liner will not wipe away. It looks great at the end of a long work day.5
I have extremely sensitive eyes and most pencils are very hard to put on. However these glided on smooth as silk and stayed on all day and did not delete a run. I recommend those eyeliners for anybody who has sensitive eyes they are absolutely amazing.5
I purchased this product while looking for eye makeup to wear for my wedding in October. I wanted something that would last all day and have been impressed with this eyeliner! It stays in place and does not smudge (have been wearing to work as a trial)! The only downside is the pencil becomes dull after each use and requires constant re sharpening.4
I was really excited to get this since i have a hard time finding waterproof pencils. This was not waterproof. It smudges right off. this was not a product for me.2
I love all of Mally beauty products. This eye liner is amazing. The color went on very smoothly and the water proof quality is superb.5
I love this eyeliner! While I wouldn't quite call it bullet proof, I would say that it stays on better than any other eyeliner I have tried. The black is deep and dark. Perfect...just as a black eyeliner should be! Love it! The problem I had was with the other color. It made my eyeballs turn blood red and itch and burn for a couple of days. So, hypoallergenic doesnt cover everyone. Now, I would say this was simple allergies but I tried it twice with the same reaction. I still thinkthat this is a great product!5
They smear off easily. Even with a good primer, the blue and black are both smudged on my upper eyelid in a matter of 60 minutes. The teal is such a pretty color that I don't mind the smeared looked, gives a pretty water-colored effect. But the black is kind of a let down. I have other brands that stay much better, so I'll continue to those instead.4