I love that this product is organic. I prefer to use natural ingredients around my eyes. The Green Lagoon color that I bought has great shimmer is too light for my complexion but looks beautiful on my mother. She can get away with a little flash but I look best with neutrals. The liner isn't as soft as I would like so it doesn't glide on smoothly. It's best to heat the tip of the pencil by blowing it with your blow dryer for a few seconds to get it to go on more smoothly. I love that the pencil sharpener is included in the lid but the lid doesn't stay on tightly and I had to root through my makeup kit to find it. That is to say the sharpener part. The lid that protects the tip of the liner itself fits on snuggly and keeps it safe from contamination. I prefer fel pencil as they are softer but for an organic alternative, this one works well.