Please enter your password to continue.
Before we met this defining liner, thoughts that came to mind when we heard the word “velvet” usually involved triple Salchows and terrible fashion choices from the past (velvet chokers, anyone?). That was then, and this is a much more beautiful now. This pencil’s creamy formula glides on smoothly for a perfectly defined eye look. And it’s smudge resistant, so unlike fleeting fashion trends, this eyeliner’s not going anywhere.
This is not my favorite eye liner. Besides the fact that I only wear black, It's not bold enough and doesn't go on very smooth. I have received some really great eye liners in my birchbox that I have repurchased but this will not be one of them.2
This product glides on great that I sampled in a navy color. Stay on power is pretty good given I have very oily eyelids.5
I love this eyeliner! The color, consistency and wear were perfect! I can not wait to order a full size.5
Color is okay. Goes on Nicely! I think I'd like it more in black. I don't wear brown normally. Sample size is perfect. Keep sending in different colors birch box!3
Not very pigmented in my opinion. Also has sparkles, and I prefer not to have that in my eyeliner. I know people who would like this however.
This is a pretty decent pencil. It has a great color. It doesn't smudge, but I do feel that it could go on a little bit more easily.3
Olive color that I wouldn't have picked BUT went on very smoothly and quite flattering for me. Brown hair, green eyes. I would purchase.5
I found this liner difficult to put on smoothly. I LOVED the purplish tent of the Mure, but I felt like I was going to scratch my eye sockets every time I tried to put it on. In addition, when I sharpen my pencil, it crumbles two out of three times. I know that they say nothing good comes easy, but this was just painful...and sad.2
I purchased this product based on a video from the Birchbox site. It looked lovely and I wanted to try something new that would make my green eyes pop. I ordered the Mure color and I experienced similar issues with other's who gave the product low reviews. When it arrived, the tip of the pencil was broken off which was frustrating. It does come with a sharpener, so I sharpened it and gave it a try. It does not glide on smoothly, or at least that has not been my experience, it actually clumps or tugs when you apply it. I'm not sure if some of the pencils/colors are defective or what, but I was very disappointed in this purchase and definitely won't be repurchasing. Although, I really like the color, I will just look for something similar in another brand.1
I am not the best at using eyeliner, but this eyeliner is so easy to apply. It lasts all day without smudging!5