Before we met this defining liner, thoughts that came to mind when we heard the word “velvet” usually involved triple Salchows and terrible fashion choices from the past (velvet chokers, anyone?). That was then, and this is a much more beautiful now. This pencil’s creamy formula glides on smoothly for a perfectly defined eye look. And it’s smudge resistant, so unlike fleeting fashion trends, this eyeliner’s not going anywhere.