Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
Brow forgery is a delicate art that’s easier than ever to master (and it’s not illegal—yet, anyway). For goofproof application, use this subtle arch-enhancer. Not only does it work for a wide range of hair colors, but it leaves us with lush, defined brows that look 100 percent genuine.
I used it twice and threw it away. It is VERY waxy, making it difficult to create a natural look.1
I have light, blonde eye brows so this pencil is perfect for me. All I have to do is a couple of swipes and it fills my eyebrows perfectly. It looks very natural which I love!4
I love benefit, and only use their products for my eyebrows, but this is just a pencil, it's not a great pencil - it's OK, definitely not worth the $$ when you can find other pencils that work equally just as well. The color is also strange, the deep color is more gray?3
The formula is really nice, very natural looking, though probably not good for those looking to add fullness to a thinner brow.
This is definitely for thicker brows, and it gives mine such a defined look without being too dark to be believable.
This is a wonderful brow pencil. It offers great coverage, is long lasting, and the brush helps to shape the finished brow.5
I think my search for the perfect eye pencil is over! I love the attached spoolie and waxy feel of the pencil. I got the shade deep and I am Asian, and it's the perfect shade. My hair color isn't necessarily black, but it's not chestnut brown either. Will be ordering more.5
This is such a great pencil. I first got this when I was trying to get comfortable filling in my lashes. I get the lights color for when my hair is lighter and then medium shade for when I decided to go a deeper brown! So awesome I'm so glad I found this!5
This product worked well but it's kind of chalky and doesn't blend well. It gets clumpy but does the job.3
I have been using this eyebrow pencil for a couple of years now. It's absolutely perfect! My eyebrows are very light and gives them great definition. It doesn't look fake, but blends in very well with my hair and skin tone. The brush at the end is a great tool to ensure that the color is applied evenly throughout the brow. I will never use a different product! This one is on my must have list.5
I am big fan of this pencil. It goes on very nicely and blends into the brows perfectly. I find it very hard to match my eyebrow color with most other brands and mediums including pomades, but this brand matches perfectly, granted they aren't selling my color on birch box right now :/ and i need a new one because i am almost out! my color is a deep brown. this is my go to everyday beauty product even if I'm running late because it is just so easy to apply! the only reason i'm giving it four instead of five stars is because it can wipe off throughout the day, but i find that is the case with all the brow products i've tried!4