Benefit They're Real! Mascara Deluxe Mini Customer Reviews

This came recommended to me, and I have no regrets buying it. Started with the sample size and can't wait to purchase the full size.

I kind of feel like the brush resembles a terrifying spiky caterpillar, so if you have a fear of those, this is probably not the mascara for you. I'm only a little scared if caterpillars and managed to get past that part. The spikes let me coat individual lashes really well without clumping. Long lasting but not difficult to remove at night.

This mascara definitely makes your eyes pop. Its not too heavy and it doesnt clump. However it is very tough to remove

I love this mascara. I've worn it to a few weddings (including my own) and put it through some pretty intense cry-tests in the process... it is bulletproof! Also perfect for daily wear.

I absolutely love this mascara. I already have long lashes, but it's the feature I like to highlight and this stuff is magic in a bottle. The brush is perfect for reaching tiny lashes in the corners of the eyes and the formula really lengthens and curls without needing a curler. While this product sticks on lashes indefinitely, it also is not waterproof and if you tear up it will flake.

I really liked how long the mascara made my lashes. It does clump for me a bit, but less than cheaper brands. The size is pretty small. It looks more like a sample. Didn't love that.

Sorry -- I didn't order this through birchbox, I'm just a user of it and had to review!!

I got this for myself because i'd tried the sample size at sephora for my birthday. I bought the full size and after about a month, the mascara became incredibly clumpy and sticky and left my eyelashes melded together as if I'd used glue on my lashes.

Getting this mascara off is a nightmare as well, I had to use make-up remover specifically because if you use just soap and water, you get racoon eyes. I never left the bottle open and I know not to pump mascara, rather I swirl. Do not get this, there are many other great types of mascara!

All the women in my family swear by this mascara! We all have different color, and thickness in lashes, but it works amazing for us all.
A MUST for your lashes.

I am very picky about my mascara and this mascara was great! I loved the brush, it made your eyelashes long and no clumps!

I was really excited about this product and had heard a lot of great things about it before finally getting a sample. The way it looked on my lashes was nice but not the best I had ever seen or expected from all the hype it got. The brush was really large and unique which may be a plus or minus for some.

The mascara had two downfalls for me - 1 very fixable, 1 not. The fixable one being that the sample wand was too short for the size of the brush. I assume this would be OK and the size would be appropriate if I purchased a full size but with the sample it just ended up being messy, getting on my eyelids and fingers. The not fixable one was it's removable. I found it to be very "sticky" for lack of a better word and it clumped my lashes together causing me to rip some out when using makeup remover. I prefer a mascara that washes off easily in the shower but that's just my preference. Nice sample but would not buy full size.