Please enter your password to continue.
As makeup trends go, we’ve pretty much tried them all. But there are some looks that transcend trend—when it comes to the smoky-eye, we’re staunch loyalists. After years of trying a variety of shadows for the perfect sultry look, we’ve officially found our one and only. This no-fuss, creamy eye shadow stick delivers easy application and high-definition color. The long-lasting formula glides on smoothly, blends easily, and is resistant to unwanted creases.
Goes on so smoothly and gives a shimmery wash of color all over. Found it to stay a long while too, even without primer. Will try and restrain myself from purchasing all of the colors, but it will be difficult.5
This is the best eyeshadow I have ever used. I don't typically spend a lot of time applying my makeup, and this is so easy and convenient. Well worth the price. Wish birchbox would carry more of her colors!5
This stick is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! I bought the orchid and love love love the look it gave my eyes. Bright, shimmery, but still grown up. I applied one handed while wresting my toddler for my blush brush and it still looks fab. Can;t believe I spent over $20 on a single color shadow but WOW I want them all now!5
This is easy to apply and the purple is a nice color.
I prefer creme stick shadows as they are quick and easy to apply and they last all day.
That said this stick seems no better than the one I purchased from CVS for $8.
I wanted to be excited about this but it left me feeling like I had wasted money.
I love these caviar sticks - I now own three. My favorite is definitely the rose gold. They go on very smooth and are great as bases, to use alone, and also to brighten eyeshadow that is a little too dark. They also last a long time!5
I bought this shadow because I had previously swatched it on my hand and it was still there two days later! The colors are gorgeous (although a few are rather frosty) and some are even dark enough to contour the eye with. I recommend Sandglow or Plum!5
This is great as a shadow, but I find the tip too thick to work as a liner now that I've used it a few times. I put it on as close to my lash line as I can and smudge it with my finger for a smokey look. I use less during the day to make my eyes pop just a little behind my glasses, and more in the evening when I want a more dramatic look.4
I love this product, I am less sure about the color (I bought it in Sapphire, and while the color is absolutely gorgeous, it a pretty heavy look for me). But very good product. My only comment would be that you have to hold it tightly otherwise it will close, which is not something I would expect from a brand like Laura Mercier.4
I tried the brushless smoky eye after watching a BB tutorial using the caviar eye color and it worked amazingly! The color stayed all day without creasing! It easy to blend with your finger. The overall look took less than ten minutes! This will be my go to look, its so simple but looks incredible. Definitely check out the video on the Birchbox blog! I used the navy kohl as a liner also :)5
I use this eye stick as an eyeliner. Very easy to apply and stays on all day. Try it, you'll like it.5