Please enter your password to continue.
As makeup trends go, we’ve pretty much tried them all. But there are some looks that transcend trend—when it comes to the smoky-eye, we’re staunch loyalists. After years of trying a variety of shadows for the perfect sultry look, we’ve officially found our one and only. This no-fuss, creamy eye shadow stick delivers easy application and high-definition color. The long-lasting formula glides on smoothly, blends easily, and is resistant to unwanted creases.
I got this in plum and it goes onto your eyelids like butter! Blending is easy, and the product stays put. I like how you can intensify the look easily, but also smudge it so you get a nicer smoky eye.4
I received this in a dark gray color, with a slight shimmer. It's a great color, my only issue is the width of the liner. It's a chubby liner, and I prefer a more thin and natural looking one. However, I do love the texture and easy application of this liner!4
Absolutely love the smudge effect with this eye colour. Goes on with an easy swipe. I like to use in between my lashes too. Really great product. Would love to try this in a chocolate brown.5
At first, I thought this stick was going to be to dark for my fair skin/brown eye combo, but I have changed my mind and now it is my go to eye make up. I don't have much time to get ready in the morning (6 month old baby gets in the way!) so I use this to add some oomph to my eyes - glide it around my eyelids, rub it in a little and add some basic liner and mascara and my face looks 10x better than it did before. Thinking of purchasing in a few different shades to have some options.5
I was so intrigued with the positive reviews on this item that I bought 2 to try. I'm glad I did! The color blends so easily and stays all day with no creasing. I don't even use an eyelid primer product. I now have 4 in different colors and couldn't be happier. The blending after application is truly amazing - so easy and effective!5
This is easy to apply and the purple is a nice color.
I prefer creme stick shadows as they are quick and easy to apply and they last all day.
That said this stick seems no better than the one I purchased from CVS for $8.
I wanted to be excited about this but it left me feeling like I had wasted money.
I love these caviar sticks - I now own three. My favorite is definitely the rose gold. They go on very smooth and are great as bases, to use alone, and also to brighten eyeshadow that is a little too dark. They also last a long time!5
I got a little ahead of myself and ordered 3 different colors. I was so disappointed at how much shimmer these things have. It was not what I was looking for. I see another reviewer had the same issue as me. The shimmer stays and the pigment doesn't. Such a shame. It's getting returned2
I bought this shadow because I had previously swatched it on my hand and it was still there two days later! The colors are gorgeous (although a few are rather frosty) and some are even dark enough to contour the eye with. I recommend Sandglow or Plum!5
This is great as a shadow, but I find the tip too thick to work as a liner now that I've used it a few times. I put it on as close to my lash line as I can and smudge it with my finger for a smokey look. I use less during the day to make my eyes pop just a little behind my glasses, and more in the evening when I want a more dramatic look.4