I received a sample of this eyeliner in a monthly box. I loved the way it glided on smoothly and the color. I thought I was reordering the same.
I found this very hard to use; had to swipe my eyelid 4 - 5 times before I saw any color! Even then, it was very light and of course with so many swipes, I now had a larger line than what i wanted, but still very faint color.
I returned the item and would not recommend or at least not this color!