Eyeko Black Magic Mascara Customer Reviews

I am a mascara FREAK. I have tried countless numbers of lengthening, strengthening, water proof, high end, low end mascaras, lash lengthening treatments, Latisse, eye lash dyes, YOU NAME IT, all in the sake of having beautiful, curled, long lashes. This mascara is the perfect formal to give you long lashes without insane clumping. This mascara is not going to physically add on those weird clumps to the tips of your lashes that, while making you look like you have spider webs for lashes, lengthen them. BUT if you are looking for a simple, 2 step (curl then apply product) this mascara will give you back your sanity and be a solid simple step. I will probably not try another mascara again. Love this brand and especially this mascara.

I like the consistency and how well it goes on however I didn't realize it was waterproof and it takes a lot to get it off

I liked the different unique packaging. It was way to squeeze out every last drop. Would prefer a more voluptuous wand. Good long lasting product

Being a swim instructor, I am always on the lookout for a good mascara that will not rub off despite splashing and swimming. I don't normally wear mascara when I know I will be swimming because I don't want to get the dreaded "raccoon eyes" and scare poor little 3 year olds. When I forgot to take it off, I was surprised to see NO smearing whatsoever! Instead, it sorta "flakes" off like most of the Clinique mascaras do. This might be annoying to some, but I would rather have mascara fleck off than smeared emo-eyes. Overall, this is a great, long wearing mascara that is just fine to get wet and perfect for a long day.

this mascara makes me feel bad in a good way. it's magically inky, and i like that wet formula. i have always enjoyed a curved brush, and felt comfortable in my hand. also the wand wasn't too long like some wands. this feels like a professional high end product, made for rockstars like me. it is a special mascara, and worth the money. love it!

This mascara was great. I really lengthened my lashes and it also helped fan them out. It didn't clump and it helped curl them too.

I didn’t care for this product. Clumpy and messy. The container was odd.

I have never used a mascara that did so much for the appearance of my short thin lashes. Most of the time I wear false lashes but sometimes I am just too lazy or running late to put them on. On those days I felt self conscious and found myself apologizing for not looking very put together but having this jewel In my arsenal I can go out confident that my eyes look great. BTW this mascara is awesome with false lashes as well. I have started wearing lighter weight lashes as this mascara adds a lush thick finish them. I am on a very tight budget so wish it was less expensive.

I've got a few samples of this by birch box and its nothing worth buying, it definitely didn't keep them curled and they clumped easily. My favorite mascara they sent me was benefits rollerlash, I'm saving money up to buy the full size.

Great color and lengthening, but it didn't thicken. It also didn't have the staying power that I want. It flaked by the end of the day. Would not purchase.