Eyeko Black Magic Mascara Customer Reviews

Absolutely waterproof! I love that I can wear this mascara through a full day of work as well as a workout session and not have mascara smudged right below my eye.

I initially received this sample about a year ago, and it was love at first use! It goes on so smoothly and makes my lashes look so long. It's the only mascara I've used that people have actually complemented my lashes and want to know what kind of mascara I use. When removing the mascara, it doesn't black out your eyes and get all over your face when it gets wet, it just comes off in rubbery long particles. Eye makeup remover also works great. Strange sounding, but I love it. The sample itself lasted a good 2 months and it was my first birch box purchase after the sample ran out. I am about to purchase it for a second time. It's that good ladies! It's also reasonably priced and when combined with my birchbox points it can't be beat! xoxox

I love this mascara because it creates little tubes on each lash making them seem so much longer and it's so easy to wash off. It doesn't get all over your face because the little tubes come off in chunks. I've bought it twice now!

This is one of the few Birchbox samples I received that I didn't like. I found it to be way too smudgy and not long lasting. It didn't provide the "wow" factors other mascaras such as Bad Gal or They're Real provide. Disappointed for sure, and I ended up throwing it out. The only pros were the cute and practical packaging and the amount of curl the mascara gave my lashes.

LOVE LOVE LOVE this product! Would highly recommend it! Makes your eyes truly pop! Perfect color and goes on smooth. Makes your lashes extra long!

I was hooked when I first used this mascara! It does not clump, makes lashes individually stand out, and gives great definition! Definitely worth a try! Some also claimed this helped curl their lashes. I'm not sure I can attest to this, but I loved this mascara!

this is one of my favorites that i also have gone back to buy the full size. with so many mascaras on the market you can be easily confused. This is the best one I have found yet and reasonably priced

This product was surprisingly long lasting without running and removed with ease using eye makeup remover. Long lasting , great length and no clumping, definitely worth a try!!

No more panda face but removes easy with eye makeup remover. Long lasting , great length and no clumping. I love it

I've been so impressed by the samples of mascaras I've received in my boxes, but this one tops the cake! It adds length and volume to your lashes and does not wear off or rub off. I've forgotten to take it off at the gym and it doesn't give me raccoon eyes like most mascaras after sweating. I'm definitely ordering more!