Stays put
I love a good lip liner, so I was excited to try this lip pencil that acts like a liner and lip stick in one. I had to knock a star, because I was expecting more of a shine. The product description says "shine of a gloss." I'd say that's a bit of a stretch. To me, this pencil goes on smooth, and feels like a lip stick. Not super glossy. It DOES, however, stay put, and the color is highly pigmented. A huge plus.
4