I'd give this 5 stars if it lasted longer on my lips. It seems to disappear if I lick my lips a couple of times. I ended up carrying in my purse for a quick fix - perfect for that, especially cheek AND lips....I learned that the lid had better be on tight. Not too tight! After having it about a year, riding in my bag, opening and putting the lid back on tightly and maybe the plastic got a little brittle, it cracked and I had a mess. Liquidy enough that in my bag with a black lining, nothing got destroyed or sticky.
I usually love EVERYTHING about Benefit. It is just a fantastic brand. I hope to eventually get around to trying every product that is relevant to my complexion.