Stila Cosmetics Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner Customer Reviews

These eyeliners by stila are so incredible, once you try them you'll never go back! The range of colors is awesome, I own the shades Stingray, Damsel, Spice, and Lionfish (as I prefer neutral eyes). Because these are waterproof, they are perfect for tight lining and water lining. True to the name, these will smudge within the first few seconds to create a sultry, blurred eyeliner effect if that is your preference. Plus, these last 8 months to a year with daily use. At $20, these eyeliners are so worth it!

CAUTION: The eyeliner does NOT retract so don't ever twist the whole stick up. This has been a problem for some, so I thought I would mention it.

The brown color is so great for making a smokey eye, or wearing on its own. I don't know how Stila does it, but it lasts allll day. For perspective, I have oily skin, live in a humid climate and usually have watery eyes. This liners looks great at the end of the day despite all this.

I wore the Mint Julip color a couple seasons back. It lasted all day long (I don't reapply makeup) and I got tons of complements. Totally impressed!!

Looking to order this in all colors ladies great brand at a great price if you love colors then this is the one for you !!!! I do put a little shadow under the borrow helps on running this brand is pretty good .........

(I would give 4 stars, but it seems like the cap falls off easily now and I've had to throw a few away.) They apply and wear so well in the waterline and on the upper and lower Lash Lines. I use these personally and in my bridal kit. Damsel, Stingray, Spice and Lionfish are my must haves. Deep Burgundy is gorgeous, too!

I have this in the Lionfish color, and it's perfect. Goes on smoothly and lasts all day!

I would give this product zero stars if it were possible. The product was hard and dry right out of the box; I am not sure if this is how the product generally is or if this was due to poor handling, but this is not something that you would want to be applying to the sensitive skin around the eye. The amount of pressure that is required to get any product onto skin is ridiculous.

This is my first time using Stilla and I was beyond excited. I assumed I'd be getting a great product since I would be spending over $20. I got the waterproof, smudgeproof white eyeliner to use on my waterline for early mornings. Nothing but disappointment. Without really any pressure, the tip breaks off. Then I spent a good two minutes twisting and twisting to get the product to come back out of the applicator and after repeatedly building, it's a shimmery dull silver at best that rubs off immediately! It also doesn't show up on my waterline!!! I wish it was possible to return items because this was a huge disappointment.

I purchased this in the color called Lionfish. The finish isn't mentioned in the description, but this is a lovely metallic bronze color. Really happy with it!

The purple tang eyeliner is divine. I love it and am always near depression when it's time for a replacement. Applies smoothly, and yes, smudges easily if that's what you want.