stila smudge stick waterproof eye liner Customer Reviews

This eyeliner definitely stays put all day, and it's certainly waterproof as it's hard to wash off. But what I really dislike about it is how 'unsmudgeable' it is. Once you put it on, it's on. You can't get a smoky eye look with this liner unless you smudge eyeshadow overtop of it.

Stayed put well. Thought the color I got did not work well with my complexion.

I loved this product. It really stays on all day long and glides on easily. I would recommend this eyeliner highly!

Great colors, but I am very disappointed that all of the Stila smudge sticks I have (5) no longer function properly (after a couple of months). Just tossed them all out! They break and/or jam when one is twisting them up to get more product. From now on I am going to use the Urban Decay 24/7 as my go-to liner.

I think the lionfish is maybe the best eyeliner color I've used, because it's got just this hint of plum to the brown that adds something extra. I find it works both with nude shadows, AND deep berries and plums. Versatile.

Any good eyeliner needs to be waterproof, and this stuff is the best. After a coat of primer, I swipe this stuff on, sometimes sweeping it into a cat eye, other times simply lining my upper waterline. It doesn't move! My skin is pretty oily, especially my eyelids for some reason. Most liners rub off after a couple of hours, but Stila made this stuff to last. The pigmentation is really concentrated too, so you don't really need a thick coat of it. Also, it doesn't take an army to remove this liner. I just use makeup removing wipes, and it gets most of it off without a fight. This is my new favorite liner.

Received the blue and then ordered the olive & purple. These colored eye liners freshen up my standard make-up routine.

LOVE this liner, own four different colors. The color is rich and glides on easily, the stick is narrow enough for precise use, and it lasts all day even with my combination/oily skin.

Not one of my favorites, I love eyeliners and when I find some amazing ones. I'm hooked, but this one did nothing to make me fall in love. I've also tried it in black. Dries out quick, atleast mine did and it does not stay in my inner lid as long as I would like it to.

I felt like this eyeliner worked very well, was easy to apply, was very easy to smudge correctly. I received this in a blue shade, however, and would have preferred a more neutral color.