Please enter your password to continue.
The quickest way to update your eye makeup? Swap your traditional black eyeliner for a rich colored one. stila’s smudge stick liners are gorgeously wearable and come in a variety of rich shades that make eyes pop. Better yet, the liners are waterproof and stay vibrant all day.
This liner is creamy, but it smudges on my oily lids after some time even with a good primer. I've also owned one in the past that I returned because the twist packaging simply did not work, although my sample from birchbox seems to be okay in that respect.3
It was a little light for me, and doesn't smudge well on the bottom eyelid. I think if it was black or grey I would've liked it better, but it stays on pretty well.3
I was not a huge fan of the color i received. I didnt feel it made my eyes pop the way eye liner usually does. I also didnt really like the consistency of it. It was not very easy to put on it an clean thin line the way I like my eye liner to be. I did really like the slight shimmer though and the smudge proof and waterproof is great for summer. I would try it in another color.3
It still smudges on my bottom lash line...but the upper lash line is fine, so I'm on the fence about purchasing it, even in a different color.3
May purchase this in another color, like the blue or purple. LOVE that it was a full size!3
I'm not a fan of eye liner, so this really did nothing for me. Plus I would never wear it in the blue color I got.3
I would probably need to sample another color that would show on my dark skin tone.3
I'm not planning to purchase because I prefer liquid liner.3
I LOVE stila smudge sticks! The only reason why I did not like this particular one is the color...I have brown eyes and tend to be very casual with my eye makeup. The green color I got does not go well with my makeup routine.3
I LOVED this stick. It really was waterproof, applied beautifully smooth, and the dark blue color was gorgeous. The only problem I had was that I actually ruined a pair of contacts using it, because it's so waterproof that it must have gotten on my contact during the day and then even soaking it in the contact solution for days did not remove the smudge it left. I passed this on to a friend who does not wear contacts and she loves it.3