Please enter your password to continue.
The quickest way to update your eye makeup? Swap your traditional black eyeliner for a rich colored one. stila’s smudge stick liners are gorgeously wearable and come in a variety of rich shades that make eyes pop. Better yet, the liners are waterproof and stay vibrant all day.
This has relatively good staying power and smooth application. It's a nice basic black liner with a gentle application. One pass gives good definition and I can also do more than one pass for greater oomph.
Main complaints: doesn't last that long.
I can't wait to try this in the morning. The color (Lionfish) is gorgeous and will work so well with all the eye shadows I currently use. And to have it smudge-proof, what more can you ask for.5
I have four colors because I love these so much. They glide on so easily. I have unfortunately had an issue with the lid cracking and the liner drying out. Be careful when placing the cap back on.4
I got this in Lionfish, and it's great for my pale skin and blue eyes. It blends really well and lasts all day.5
I'm new to eyeliner and am so glad I started with stila! The Lionfish is a wearable brown but the Moray is my favorite...it really highlights the gold in my hazel-green eyes. Very forgivable application for someone who applies it with a toddler grabbing her leg.4
I have five of these liners and I use one everyday. My favorite is the Angelfish, because it helps brighten up my eyes. Peacock is another favorite, although the color is very intense! I've found that they do tend to fade a bit throughout the day, and I do live in a dry climate so I don't worry much about smudging after application. I haven't experienced any trouble with drying out or defective applicators, as well. Overall, they have been a great liner for every occasion.4
I have oily eyelids but this liner stayed on through swimming and a very hot day!! Love this and will get more5
This eyeliner went on nicely and was a good color, but it didnt last long. It was usually completely gone within an hour or two.3
This is one of the better products I have used, and I love the color, but with very deepset eyes and wearing the eyeliner on the lower lid, it inevitably migrates down to make half-moons of color under my eyes. Keep trying to make this product truly non- migrating!!!4
Once again Stila has some of the best liners on the market. I have this eye liner in the color golden olive and it's for just pop of color on my lower lash line. It's waterproof but comes off with ease when using makeup remover.4