Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
The quickest way to update your eye makeup? Swap your traditional black eyeliner for a rich colored one. stila’s smudge stick liners are gorgeously wearable and come in a variety of rich shades that make eyes pop. Better yet, the liners are waterproof and stay vibrant all day.
This liner is great for keeping in my purse. Its easy to apply and gives a great long-lasting liner. My only complaint is that its a little difficult to remove completely, even with eye makeup remover and face wash.4
I feel like I've tried them all. I've got a simple kohl eyeliner I wear for days when I don't feel like trying. I've got liquid eyeliners and gel eyeliners. . . I like this stila liner better and think it has more lasting power than everything else, including products from competitive brands like bareminerals and Urban Decay 24/7. This eyeliner doesn't "smudge" as much as you would think from its name. In fact, if you don't fix any mistakes quick, they are staying there. I wear contacts, and this eyeliner is gentle enough for me to wear all day, tight-line, waterline, and all. But mostly I save it for glam nights out. Choose this eyeliner before your next fancy eye look. The pencil format makes it easy to control, and you can adjust the intensity to your liking. I know you won't be disappointed!5
For me personally at least, colored eyeliner isn't used regularly. Therefore, I don't know if I would invest this much into this product again since I barely use it. I usually buy cheaper products for trendy colors. I will say, however, that this product is better than many cheaper products containing glitter because the glitter is very tiny shimmer pieces that are integrated into the formula. Sometimes, cheaper formulations have big pieces of glitter that fall off or irritate eyes.3
I love the dark green color and slight shimmer of this eyeliner -- flawless application and long-lasting. Could not ask for more.5
I bought this eyeliner because every eyeliner that I have used ends up smudging by the end of the day on my upper eyelid. Someone recommended this one to me and being perfect for that problem, but it's no different than any other eyeliner I've tried. It goes on really well, but still smudges quickly. Still looking for a true smudge proof liner...1
This is so easy to apply. Even when a slight smudge appears, it is easy to fix. I only wish the other colors were available. Still, the black works. It goes on - not too thick and not too thin!5
My very first birchbox brought me an eyeliner I had never tried before, but was EXACTLY what I was looking for. Once I tried this eyeliner, I was sold. I have never found one that stays on so well. I wear hard contacts and eyeliner usually ends up underneath my eyes by the end of the day. Not this stuff. I ended up purchasing about 8 others and they are just the best. I love the colors and the hint of shimmer. The one I got in my birchbox (purple tang, which looks more navy blue/blackish when it's on) is the one I've loved the best. It doesn't glide on an easily as Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliner, but the staying power is WAY better.5
I love this eyeliner! The staying power is fantastic! I applied it in the morning and smudge it a bit, and it stays on all day long. Very happy with this product. =)1
I was somewhat underwhelmed by this product. It is a very nice liner, but it's been sooo hyped up that I expected something amazing, and it didn't deliver for me. I found that it doesn't have good staying power, even though it's supposed to be waterproof. The color (I chose peacock) is very nice, but it applies unevenly (was left with a line that was stop/go and also chunks in many places). Additionally, it's not an inexpensive product, and I found that there are other cheaper liners on the market that have better results, and are packaged almost exactly the same, and the one I'm talking about is literally pretty much the exact same product (if not for the brand name on the outside, I wouldn't be able to tell the two apart). I will not be purchasing this liner again.2
I bought this liner in purple. It has very bright glitter embedded in the line. It stays, it's beautiful, and the purple is more blue than red. I wish there were a built in sharpener.4