Consistency varies by color
I received a sample of Sumita Eyeliner in a Birchbox that I loved, so I picked up this sample pack of basic colors for more variety. I like the regular gold best for giving a little pop to my eye make-up. I've had some issues with the pencil crumbling at the tip and breaking off but it seems to only happen on the dark brown and black, not the metallics so I assume it has to due with the composition of substances?
Highly recommend this pack if you have enjoyed a Sumita sample and want to add some good basics to your stash. The metallics they offer are even better than Urban Decay.