I tend to do one scent at a time, and I was getting towards the end of my J'Adore. I always liked the fragrance, but it ended being a little light and sweet while I was wearing it. I first got this as a sample.
As a side note, I'm nearly 40 and I don't want a girl fragrance - I want a woman fragrance. As soon as I put this on, I knew it was exactly what I was looking for! I didn't get the "rocker" part, but it's feminine, but sophisticated, and more modern than, say, Chanel no. 5 (which is sophisticated, but always smelled like an older woman to me). I get compliments on this every time I wear it.