Please enter your password to continue.
I purchased Midnight/Caribbean Sea. I was looking for a green eye pencil and thought this would be pretty. It really is. It's a green-blue color, very mermaid-y, but not over the top at all. The Caribbean Sea, when worn on my top lash line, stays all day and the color stays true. The Midnight, however, I wore on my bottom lash line and it did not stay at all! I don't know about it being rub proof, because I don't rub my eyes. I purchased this due to the great reviews, which goes to show once again that when it comes to makeup, rub proof depends on the individual. Still going to use the Caribbean Sea, just not the Midnight.2