I received this as a sample last year and it quickly replaced my fancy brand. I love that it's not oily and if you are simply correcting a eye make up boo-boo, you don't need to start from square one. I wish this product was in travel bottles(like the one I sampled), this is perfect for the gym.
I have let it soak on a cotton ball for a minute on each waterproof mascaraed eye and it comes off with out a lot of tugging. Good job!