I got this in the Moss color. It is very pigmented and a lovely color.
I like the application. It's easy to use.
I did not use primer and the color leaked out instead of staying in my perfect line! To be fair, I did not try it with primer.
The main reason I'm only giving it two stars is because I am looking for a smudge-proof and water-proof liner. This smudged after just two hours of wear. By the end of the day (about 7 hours of wear) I literally had no liner left at all. I wasn't even out doing anything, just chilling at home. Not worth it for the money.