I'd never tried Smashbox before but had heard good things. Really though, I am just not that impressed.
The mascara is ok, but there's a couple of drug store brands I prefer. The lid primer is DRY and I have to tug on my lid to get it on and spread out.
The face primer is ok - it minimizes pores but that's not a problem for me - I'm blessed with small pores and this does little to do anything for me. I was really disappointed- I'd only heard good things about it, but I personally don't find it of any benefit at all.
The lipgloss is ok. Just ok. I guess I am glad I did get to try it, but I'm not going to be that willing to want to spend much on other Smashbox products. There's much better products in this price range, IMO.