I LOVE this mascara! First got it as a sample and I used every last drop until I finally had to buy a full sized one. The mascara goes on smooth and thick. I give the mascara 5 stars.
The eyeliner is nice. I like the idea of it...there is a soft, fine applicator tip. This makes applying the eyeliner super easy. The only problem is that the color does not come out dark enough. I have to spend more time than I would like to in order to get some color to show. So, the eyeliner gets 3 1/2 stars.