The eyliner was just okay (I got silver, and honestly, 90% of the time, I just don't see the point of colored eyeliners.)
It wasn't terrible, but it also wasn't great.
The biggest disappointment though, was in the sharpener. What I thought was a clever idea at first, turned out to be useless, as the sharpener itself is too small to allow the pencil far enough in to be sharpened at all.
And in the long run, unless you plan to keep the sharpener (assuming it works), it's pretty wasteful. Just buy a better eyeliner, and a separate sharpener you can actually use.