The Yes To Carrots lip balm is a solid product. It is many steps above ChapStick, and I find it less sticky than many other lip balms, such as the Burt's Bees varieties. It's slightly more firm than other lip balms I have tried, taking an extra swipe or two to get a good coverage.
I received the melon, and I like that the taste and smell aren't overpowering.
I prefer the Pangea Organics lip balms, but I'll be tossing my Yes To Carrots sample into a bag or coat pocket and expect to get some good use out of it.
I have no qualms recommending this item for those who want an low-cost and effective lip balm.