I received the shade Blue Lagoon as a sample. It's a fun electric blue color that's perfect for summer. I wish the formula worked for me because the color is nice.
The consistency is creamy, but not too soft either. It applies easily, although I had to go over it 2 to 3 times for full opacity.
The formula claims to be waterproof, but it is not. I always test waterproof products by wearing them in the shower. I let the water splash my face periodically. I gently pat my eyes if water gets in them, but do not rub them. Ideally with a waterproof formula, everything looks just as good when I get out as when I went in. I had only applied this liner to my upper lids, but came out of my shower with bright blue raccoon eyes under each eye.
I could get over this if the formula wore well otherwise, but it keeps flaking and smudging on me when all I'm doing is sitting inside in the air conditioning. As much as I want to like this liner, I'm not a fan.