I was incredibly excited to try these three after hearing about them from Tati's youtube channel. I've come to trust her recommendations on what are quality products. I now need to reassess that trust. :(
They do feel VERY soft on my lips and go on like a balm, which was nice, and I actually like the colors themselves, (hence the two stars) but when I looked into the mirror 10 minutes after applying, it had slid all over the place, leaving an uneven coat, and spreading outside of my lips and lip liner which made me look like a clown!
I tried again this morning with less product, but the same thing happened again, it just was lighter this time. This is not my first rodeo with lipstick so I'm not sure what's up with these, they're just not the quality I expect from Birchbox. Did I get a bad batch? Was this a fluke?