I tried this mascara yesterday for the first, and last, time. I was looking forward to the waterproof situation so much and, while it may very well be waterproof, it isn't flake-proof.
This mascara started flaking directly into my eyes less than 2 hours into my day. I hadn't been rubbing or wiping my eyes til that point so I'm not sure what caused it....
The flakes were sharp, Painful, and constant enough to where I'm done with this mascara and this entire company's eye makeup product line.
My eyes are red and irritated today... I've got my eyedrops close at hand.
Yikes! No thanks, Birchbox!