I was highly disappointed in this offering from Stila since I'm usually a fan of their product!
The mascara was clumpy, flakey, and smudgy, all the things you DON'T want! I want to blame it all on the formula but the brush wasn't great either. I've used this type of wand shape in the past, but this one just didn't work great.
The mascara went on clumpy and flaked all over by the end of the day. Within a few hours, my mascara was already smudged all along my lower eye line.
I liked the tone of black, but that's about it. Everything else about this mascara was a total failure, one of the worst I've tried in a while.