After reading other reviews, I'm wondering if I just got one from a bad batch.
I like Smashbox products and I was excited to try this - it went on pretty smooth, but it turned into an icky almost gummy texture when it made contact with my eyelashes. Plus, it flaked off. it was terrible! I was already running late for a dinner, or else I would've taken all of my makeup off and started over....but didn't have time. I had to use a safety pin to separate my eyelashes they were so gummed together.
Sadly, this is going in the garbage.