First of all, I received spray vials which I prefer, not rollerball. So don't unscrew the top or you will likely spill some perfume as I did! Not sure why it says rollerball on the information. My favorite is Paris, but New York comes in a close 2nd. Similar style. I would purchase a full size New York next time. Provence is nice, but not at all what I expected. Provence is a bit heavy, not as floral as I had hoped considering the description. The packaging was very nice. Vials well protected in the box. I used my points toward purchase of this set. I already purchased the larger bottle of Paris, so these vials were bought to try out Catherine Malandrino's other fragrances.