Always Free Shipping for Birchbox Aces
Free standard shipping on orders $50+
Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
I have found lately i have a sensitivity to certain eye makeup products and this is just one more to add to that list. Even Bare Escentuals eyeliner makes my eyes water, and i use BE all over, so that's pretty annoying. I will say that i love the color, i love the application, but if your eyes water then that kind of defeats the purpose :( I'll be giving it to a friend who i'm sure will love it.
I love this stuff. I prefer to use a pencil type eyeliner instead of liquid. I don't have a steady hand. But, I haven't found an eyeliner that goes on smoothly and stays all day. This stuff is amazing. The color is vibrant and I get compliments all the time (was using the dark blue) and it lasts all day without getting raccoon eyes by 3pm. My mom has been harassing me to order her some and I just ordered two more.
Highly recommend it!
I got the sailor blue eyeliner in a different subscription box and loved it. Mally eyeliner is now the only one I use. So, I thought I'd try another color, and ordered the purple. Love it too. This eyeliner goes on so smoothly, stays on all day, and doesn't smudge at all. Best eyeliner on the market.
The liner went on like a dream! I've had a lot of problems with other eyeliners, and the only problem I have with this one is trying to get it off. It lasts forever and glides like a dream. I bought it in black, and I'm thinking about the plum...
I was excited to buy this eyeliner because the information page about it said "rub-proof" and that after setting for 30 seconds, the line wouldn't move: "a smooth, precise line that stays put all day."
I am incredibly disappointed in the performance. After letting it set for 60 seconds, it smudged as soon as I ran my finger along my eyelid. I waited ten more minutes, and the line along my other eye smudged under very light touch.
The color glides on smoothly, but it does not stay put and it is not by any measure "rub proof."
This is the perfect shade - it is blue, it is grey, it is navy - it's all three!! Plus a little subtle shimmer. This can be paired with almost any shade and it works great for daytime wear and it an awesome shade if you have blue or hazel eyes. Buy it ;0)
This is my new favorite eye-liner. I will actually purchase this. It's a fabulous color and really accents my eyes. I don't even need to wear eye shadow. just eye liner and mascara!
This eye liner goes on so easily and doesn't smudge! I love the lucky penny color and have gotten so many compliments on it. The color usually fades a bit throughout the workday but it's not significant and I have never had a problem with smudging. This is easily my favorite!
The quality of this eyeliner is amazing. Stays on all day long!! It is a fabulous product. So excited to find it!
I love the color, but it just doesn't stay on well. It smudges easily after just 3 hrs. I wish I could use it more because the color is stunning.