I am so happy BB introduced me to JB. I have ingredient sensitive skin, and some of the worst culprits are eyeliners and mascaras. This JB eyeliner (in black) is a Godsend! Finally, something that doesn't burn my eyes. I've tried other vegan/natural/organic eyeliners, and well, this is the best performing one with the happiest ingredients. Honestly, it goes on and stays put just as well as any other good eyeliner.
P.S. I wear this stuff mowing my one acre lawn, and it doesn't smudge, doesn't even feel like I'm wearing eyeliner, and it's still there after I sweat in the heat and humidity.