I'm surprised this has such high reviews. It's just ok. Recently, I've been wearing BENEFIT COSMETICS
They're Real! Mascara. While it's not a waterproof mascara, it can be tough to remove. My regular face wash wasn't cutting it, so I ordered this hoping it would make the task easier. It's not very effective. The formula is gentle, but I ended up having to keep going over the same area several times, and it still didn't take everything off. The extra rubbing irritated my eyes. Being 36, I try to be careful not to tug too much and cause pre-mature aging, especially around the eye area. Disappointed in this product. Within the same order, I also ordered LA FRESH® Waterproof Makeup Remover (Individual Packets). They are awesome and took everything off right away without irritation or extra tugging at the eye area. I think most eye make is going to require something with some oils to release the makeup from the skin. I would not recommend this product.