Oh I so wanted to like this eyeliner. But it fell short of my expectations. I was looking for an eyeliner that was waterproof, easy to apply, safe to use on the waterline, and stayed put after a long day.
This eyeliner took a lot of swipes to draw on, and really pulled at my eyelid as I was doing so - which is not great for the delicate skin around the eyes. The color did not draw on bold - so which was why it took several swipes to get the right color.
It was waterproof - about 80 % of it stayed put, but it did smudge. No luck with it staying on my waterline either.
So I was bummed and had to return it. For $22 I would expect it to be better.