I received my first eyeliner via my Birchbox samples.. I loved it so much I bought a “kit” that included another liner, the black magic mascara and a brow gel. The mascara and gel are FANTASTIC. The liners... not so much. While I loved them when i first received them... here we are... not quite 2 months later and they are both completely dried out. And yes. They are kept tightly capped and stored in my makeup walk-in! I could see one of them doing that.. eventually. But not this soon after receiving.
Do some more ready of reviews before purchasing!