Not sure I’d spend the money on this. I got two of them in two different boxes, and I was excited to compare this to the $7 Maybelline Master Precise I’ve been using for years. The Smith & Cult goes on nicely, but the Still Riot in mine was more of a medium gray rather than black... others claim theirs was very black,so it seems like the quality is hit or miss.
Okay this liner is great!! It stays even if I run my finger directly over it. I got to try it out during a makeover session with Smith & Cult stylists at the Birchbox Soho store and I fell in love. I have constant dry eye issues with my contacts and when I put a lot of eye makeup on I tend to get itchy eyes so it's important to me that I have a liner that won't rub away or smudge immediately when I have to itch the corner of my eye. I forgot this was even on, rubbed my eye, panicked, and then realized the liner did not budge at all. SOLD!
I received this as an extra sample in a purchase. I was excited to try it, but the product comes out watery and you can't see the color. I'm not sure what the problem is. :(
I got this as a free add-on in my December box, and it's definitely one of the better liquid eyeliners I've tried. Not my favorite because the pen line isn't the cleanest, but the consistency is great!
Eyeliner was good
The eyeliner was a nice touch in my December box. I have tried a bunch of felt tip liners and I did like this one. The color was true black and it had a long wear time. Over it was a decent product probably good for beginners.