I went with this wallet, because I too have fallen for having a overstuffed wallet that just had too much stuff in it! This thing is crisp and clean. It has everything you need in it and doesn't have that clunky feel like my old wallet.
Very nice little wallet
Card pocket on either side of the central pocket can hold 2 cards each fairly comfortably. and the central pocket can keep a good amount of cash before getting bulgy.
Leather looks beautiful. I'm sure it will age very well. My only concern is that the side seams appear to have been sealed with a liquid vinyl, so I have concerns about how the edges will age/if it will start to fray.
Slim and Convenient
I've been experimenting with slim wallets after rocking a super thick billfold for too many years. This wallet has been almost perfect, easy access to any card's that I need (I can fit 6 comfortably: id, credit, debit, health insurance, metro, coffeeshop rewards).
My only issue, and it is a little one, is that the middle pocket isn't quite wide enough to easily fit your fingers into to pull out individual bills. I usually just end up pulling out a wad of bills.
ID Card Holder
I bought one of these to carry my work ID and metrocard instead of fishing through my purse every time. I love it, except I find it so handy that I want to stuff it more stuff but alas, it won't fit.