I wasn't too keen on this milk-makeup product as I was the umbame mascara once I tried it. Don't get me wrong, it does makeup mistakes--but with with quite a bit more effort than it probably should. I tried them for the first time during my morning makeup routine after messing up my eyeliner, and I had to scrub and scrub and scrub, until it finally came off. The only problem is that these swabs tend to leave a dark black charcoal smudge wherever your little "uh-oh!" was. And was wearing a bright purple eyeliner that day, not black. Well, back to the drawing board milk-makeup! Better luck next time!