For one thing there is only 3 to choose from. The U3 and U4 are to dark for my skin time. So I got U2 in hopes that it would be close. I should have got U2.... Because U2 is soooo light that it makes me look weird. I have been using it as a under eye brightening, but it just doesn't match at all. I'm giving a 3 because there's 3 to choose from and I doubt many will match most women. Plus, when I do put it on (even with the moisturizer and Face primer) it still feels and looks so dry. I don't know, maybe if I got the middle shade it might work better. I just don't want to purchase anymore. I'll stick to my other concealers that match my skin tone better.