I liked the effects of the liner, it worked well and didn't smudge. However as soon the point was gone I was unable to sharpen it. It is not a typical pencil. So I was stuck and unable to use the rest of the eyeliner. Wish I had known this before, disappointing.
I actually forgot I had this. I love it! It goes on smooth and STAYS on!! I will be buying one of these!
Like it, but was short-lived
I liked the product, it generally applied well, and was relatively long-lasting. However, I could not sharpen it once it wore down, so the point became blunt and it didn't apply as well. It wasn't self sharpening and needed to be sharpened, but it couldn't be. Not sure if I would buy again for that reason.
Noir Longwear Eyeliner
I didn't care for this at all. I found this too wide to apply.
I usually stick to the liquid cat eye, but whenever I'm itching for a stick eyeliner day, I always reach for this one. It goes on so smooth and really stays intact for a while! I love this pencil :)
Great black pigment but didn't apply as well in my waterline. Still makes a great eyeliner if you are using for the lid
Easy to use
I'm not a huge eye liner person, but wanted to change up my eye look one night and decided to try it out. Not only did it go on very smooth, it stayed on all day, which in my experience is rare.
Goes on smooth and stays put
I have been using this as my main liner since I recieved it in my box. I usually don't like pencils because I hate sharpening them and they tend to pull, but I found that this one goes on pretty smooth and seems to have decent staying power but washes off easily with just cleanser
I have ALWAYS had issues with eyeliner running since I have very oily skin. Also, since I have dry eyes I tend to blink a lot so it usually makes my eyeliner run. I know that I will never find a pencil that is 100% run proof but this is the best I've ever tried and I've tried a lot. I was amazed at how it glides on so smoothly for being such long lasting. There is some fading by the end of the day (if you look closely) but it seems to be expected from a pencil. I read other comments that said it doesn't sharpen. I've never had an issue with this and I've been using this same liner for about a year. It has lasted me forever with frequent sharpening.
Long lasting and easy applying
I always struggle to find a great pencil eyeliner. I do not use liquid eyeliner but want to get a solid liquid look with the pencil. I went out on a limb and tried the noir cosmetics product based upon all the great reviews. I was also skeptical because water resistant eye liners usually really bother me, especially when applying to the water line. I can say, this product is solid. I have no eye irritation and it is really smooth to apply. I've noticed that it lasts all day as well. This is now my go-to liner.