The bad first: for the price that this retails at, I'm pretty irritated with the packaging. My bottle arrived dinged up and filthy (how long has Birchbox had these bottles in the warehouse? Based on the layer of dirt on my bottle, I'd guess a minimum of a year), which worries me due to concerns about how long a product like this can keep. Also irritating is the fact that the white rubber on the cap has greyed with age, which ruins the aesthetics of the packaging. Final gripe: I'm fairly sure my bottle is missing a bit of product, as it seems suspiciously empty relative to its size. Never having used this product before, though, I can't be sure.
The jury's still out on this product's efficacy — I just received my bottle today, and am waiting to see how it works now that the weather is getting colder and my skin is thirstier. For now, it seems like an ok, if rather overpriced, oil.