I'd probably give this a 3.5 if that was an option. It is a good size and it lasts a while. The smell is a little off putting for me, almost smells masculine and earthy at the same time. This stuff is good, it's just not great, yes it cleans my face, leaves it feeling okay, it's just definitely not something I think I would buy again. I have had acne and sensitive skin my whole life, so the upside is that it doesn't effect my sensitive skin, BUT it does nothing for acne, or redness or clearing the face.