Birchbox had two shades available: light and dark. I usually go for medium-light, so I ordered the "light." I tried it today, and it made me ghost-like pale. I looked at the bottle, and it was "fair," which is not at all "light." I looked up the product on another website, and there is indeed an actual "light" shade, which is 2-3 shades darker than this "fair" shade. Birchbox's categorization of these shades as "light" and "dark" is such a misrepresentation of the actual product they send. This makes is frustrating to do business with BirchboxI will return this product. If I ever try it again, I will certainly purchase it elsewhere.