I was an avid user of Benefit's Erase Paste, I loved how creamy it was and the way it blends easily by just gently patting with your finger. BUT, I didn't love that it had a very "dewey" look...which is nice for cheeks and eyelids but sort of draws too much attention to under the eye if you're puffy. So I decided to try this. And for me at least, it seemed to dry really quickly which made it harder to really blend in well. And it seems to highlight creases. Also didn't really notice any decrease is dark circles. It's an ok product, but my search continues!